GAF vs CertainTeed Shingles

Compare the two leading shingle manufacturers to choose the best brand for your roof.

GAF and CertainTeed are North America's two largest shingle manufacturers, both offering premium products. GAF Timberline HDZ costs $90-$110 per square while CertainTeed Landmark costs $85-$105 per square. For a detailed price-per-product breakdown, see our comprehensive GAF vs CertainTeed price comparison.

GAF Wins

Ties

CertainTeed Wins

Head-to-Head Comparison

Price Per Square

CertainTeed wins

GAF

Timberline HDZ: $90-$110/sq. HDZ RS: $110-$135/sq. Camelot II: $160-$210/sq.

CertainTeed

Landmark: $85-$105/sq. Landmark PRO: $105-$130/sq. Presidential: $170-$225/sq.

Warranty Options

Tie

GAF

Golden Pledge: 50-yr non-prorated material + 25-yr workmanship backed by GAF.

CertainTeed

5-Star SureStart PLUS: 50-yr limited material + workmanship via ShingleMaster.

Wind Resistance

GAF wins

GAF

130 MPH standard with LayerLock technology on all Timberline HDZ.

CertainTeed

110 MPH base (Landmark). 130 MPH on Landmark PRO with NailTrak.

Impact Resistance

Tie

GAF

Class 4 via ArmorShield II and Timberline HDZ RS (UL 2218 rated).

CertainTeed

Class 4 via Landmark PRO IR designation (UL 2218 rated).

Algae Protection

GAF wins

GAF

StainGuard Plus: 25-year algae warranty. Copper-release technology.

CertainTeed

StreakFighter: 10-15 year algae protection depending on product line.

Color Options

Tie

GAF

20+ colors across Timberline lines. Widest HDZ color selection.

CertainTeed

18+ colors. NaturalWood palette popular for Southern home styles.

Our Verdict

Both GAF and CertainTeed produce exceptional shingles. GAF wins on wind resistance (130 MPH standard) and algae protection (25-yr). CertainTeed wins on entry-level pricing ($5-10/sq less). For a full pricing breakdown including installed costs for Charlotte homes, see our detailed GAF vs CertainTeed price comparison page.

View Full Price Comparison with Detailed Product Breakdown